"So he's Santa's lighthouse." Yup, that's how she's going to think of Rudolph from now on.

Apollo doesn't give Blaine the chance to toss it, because during his deliberation she decides that he's being too slow in his decision and that thing is shiny and she wants to see it. So, she plucks it from his hand, rips the package open and pretty much just marvels at the simple shininess of whatever she was holding. "Shit you guys really like your fuckin' shine this time of year, don'tcha?"